Saturday, June 27, 2015

*Himachal tribeswomen entitled to ancestral property* : High Court

Good tidings from the foothills of the Himalayas

Himachal tribeswomen entitled to ancestral property: HC
Pratibha Chauhan & Vijay Arora

Tribune News Service

Shimla, June 25

Tribal women of Himachal Pradesh who have been fighting a battle for a share in their ancestral property got a shot in the arm today with the High Court saying they are entitled to inherit property in accordance with the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

In order to protect women against social injustice and exploitation, the court said women belonging to the tribal areas of the state will inherit property under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and not as per customs and usages. The court, while underlining that gender discrimination amounted to violation of fundamental rights, observed that law must evolve with time if societies are to progress. Women from various parts of Kinnaur have formed the Mahila Kalyan Parishad under the chairpersonship of Rattan Manjari from Ribba to seek equal share in ancestral property. They had even sought the intervention of the National Commission for Women and the National Tribal Commission in their fight for equal property rights and necessary amendment to the customary laws.

“This entire talk about gender equality holds no meaning for tribal women in Kinnaur, Lahaul-Spiti, Bharmour and Pangi since we do not get a share in ancestral property,” said Ratan Manjari.

“It is made clear by way of abandoned precaution that the observations made only pertain to right to inherit the property by the daughters under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and not any other privileges enjoined by the tribals in the tribal areas,” the judgment read.

The court further observed that gender discrimination violates fundamental rights.

While passing the order, Justice Rajiv Sharma observed: “Article 15 of the Constitution of India prohibits discrimination on the ground of sex. Articles 38, 39 and 46 envisage socio-economic justice to the women. Rule of law should establish uniform pattern in the society.” He observed that women had to be socially and economically advanced to bestow upon them dignity. The daughters in a society, who are Hindu, cannot be left and segregated from the main stream as they are entitled to equal share in the property. 

Reference: The Tribune: Himachal tribeswomen entitled to ancestral property: HC

Monday, June 1, 2015

Families impacted by serious mental illness in India are vulnerable...

...to indifference, harassment, harshness, predators, easy targets for very rude patronising behavior… Unsolicited advice is available in plenty, concrete support little. 

To preserve the person hood of a family member with serious mental illness is critical. It comes with the knowledge of knowing the person. It cannot be taught.


Giving care on a daily basis to a family member with serious mental illness takes most of a 24 hour day. The quantum of provision of care varies. Periods of intense supportive care are needed to be provided during psychosis, life threatening self-neglect, attempts at suicide …which are acute emergencies till a period of stability is reached.

Most people in India, even the educated and the aware, do not have easy access to inpatient beds in hospitals so crisis is managed at home with OPD visits to a psychiatrist the frequency of which increase during a crisis and relapse.

If one is fortunate to have sufficient financial resources, making appointments, visits to a dentist and other medical practitioners are helpful as a loved one grows older with a serious mental illness.

Medication management, easing the side effects, has to be ensured sensitively which is not easy with a lot of prowling predators discouraging treatments and offering all sorts of cures. The absence of IEC (Information Communication Education) campaigns which was one of the objectives of the National Mental Health Programme launched in India decades ago has been very favourable for *the growth of these predators*.

When a family has more than one family member with mental illness in India, to sustain the daily living activities without helpful support is very difficult. Tragedy follows and left behind is just the...remains. 


It happened recently with a family in Thiruvananthapuram in Kerala.

A print media report is given below
28 May 2015:

When Prasannakumaran paid scant heed to policemen who advised him to take his mentally ill son to a doctor, little did he know that the boy's actions would claim his wife's life. In a tragic incident, a 48-year-old woman died at Alamcode near Attingal, allegedly after her teenage son bludgeoned her using a traditional lamp (nila vilakku) in the early hours of Wednesday. Police identified the deceased as Ushakumari of Pallimukku near Alamcode under Attingal police station. Police have arrested her 19-year-old son, Akhil alias Vishnu, in connection with the incident. The murder took place when his father Prasannakumaran and sister Aparna were sleeping over at relative's house nearby.

Attingal circle inspector M Anil Kumar said Vishnu, who had been mentally unstable for the past three years, had been in a violent mood since Tuesday morning and the tragedy could have been averted had the family taken him to a hospital. "Yesterday morning, he stabbed his father's hand using a knife in a violent fit of rage," Anil Kumar said. In the evening, he went to Alamcode Junction and created a ruckus, following which local residents summoned the police. Cops arrived on the spot and took him into custody. When his relatives approached police and sought his release, the cops advised them to take him to a hospital, but in vain. Above all, the family left Ushakumari who was also under treatment for mental illness with her violent son in the house.

"After he was stabbed in the morning, Prasannakumaran did not have the courage to return home. He also asked his 22-year-old daughter Aparna to accompany him to the relative's house," the inspector said. On Wednesday morning, Prasannakumaran visited the hospital to tend to his injury and then returned to his house. Upon reaching home, he saw Vishnu sitting in front of the house, his body drenched in blood. Terrified, he summoned a few local residents and entered the house through the back door to find his wife lying in a pool of blood in the living room. The room had blood all over, including on the walls and ceiling. "It is suspected that the boy may have struck her down with the lamp and then clubbed her repeatedly on the head, causing the blood to spray out," police said.

The accused was produced before court and remanded in judicial custody. The magistrate has forwarded a letter to the Attingal sub-jail superintendent to subject the accused to a medical test to ascertain whether he was indeed mentally ill as claimed by the family. A copy of the letter has been forwarded to the district medical officer too. Vishnu, had dropped his studies after Class X owing to his mental illness. He often turned violent when he was denied money to eat food from outside. Prasannakumaran is a former NRI, who is currently into real estate business. Ushakumari was a homemaker.


Responses: 
1. A mother with mental illness who needed to be given supportive care died and her son with mental illness who should have been taken for emergency treatment has entered the criminal justice system.

2. Where is the assistance offered to the smallest social unit in society when a family member has mental illness? 

3. Where is the protection offered to the smallest social unit in society when a family member has mental illness? 


4. India has ratified many treaties which clearly state that assistance and protection should be given to preserve the family the smallest social unit in society which is not happening. 


5. 'The Kerala Joint Hindu Family System (Abolition) Act, 1975 has already stripped many families of the traditional rights, support, comfort and protection of Joint families.


References:
1. The UN Convention Rights of Persons with Disabilities
2. The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
3. The Kerala Joint Hindu Family System (Abolition) Act, 1975
4. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
5.  The Hindu

6. The Times of India